Have you ever left a meeting thinking everyone was on the same page, only to find out later that people had plenty of concerns? The timeline wasn't realistic. Something important had been overlooked. Someone saw a problem coming but kept it to themselves.
In the meeting, though, everyone was pleasant. There were a few nods; someone said, "Sounds good," and you moved on. It looked like agreement, but there was a whole other conversation you weren't part of.
A room full of polite people isn't necessarily a room where people feel free to tell the truth. Sometimes it means people have learned which conversations are worth the risk and which ones are easier to have after you leave.
I read a case study recently about a leadership team whose members worked well together but held back from saying what they really thought. People were polite, but they were cautious about being candid. It made me wonder how often we see everyone getting along and assume they feel comfortable being honest.
When I talk about civility, I mean how we treat each other, including when we disagree. There has to be room to say, "I see this differently," or "I'm concerned about what we're asking people to do." If being respectful means never making anyone uncomfortable, we'll miss a lot of important conversations.
This is where psychological safety comes in. Can someone admit a mistake, ask a question, challenge a decision, or give you feedback without worrying that they'll be embarrassed, dismissed, or penalized for it? Can they be honest when the honest answer is something you may not want to hear?
That doesn't mean every conversation feels comfortable or every suggestion gets adopted. Someone can feel nervous about raising a concern and still trust that you'll treat them fairly. The question is whether that trust holds up once they start talking.
As leaders, we have a lot of influence over that answer. We may say we welcome feedback, but people also pay attention to what happens when they give it to us.
Maybe someone tells you that your last-minute requests are making it difficult to manage their workload. You explain how much pressure you're under and remind them that priorities change. Both things may be true, but did you leave any room to understand what they were trying to tell you?
Or someone questions a decision in a meeting, and you say, "We've already talked about this." You may feel that you're keeping the conversation moving. They may leave wondering whether you wanted their perspective in the first place.
It doesn't take a dramatic reaction to make someone more cautious next time. A sigh, an irritated look, crossed arms while they're speaking, or an interruption can send a message before we've even responded to their concern. And the person speaking isn't the only one paying attention. Everyone watching is learning something about what might happen when they have a concern of their own.
I know receiving feedback can be uncomfortable. We work hard, we care about doing a good job, and it can sting to hear that something we did made someone else's work harder. Sometimes our first instinct is to explain ourselves because we want the other person to understand we meant well.
But feedback is data, not identity. We can listen to someone's experience without turning it into a verdict on who we are as a leader. We can also take it seriously without agreeing with every part of it.
That might sound like, "I didn't realize my requests were landing that way. Can you walk me through what happened?" Or, "I have a different perspective, but I want to understand yours before I respond." Those responses give the conversation somewhere to go.
Sometimes we'll need a minute to settle our own reaction. We can say, "I want to give this some thought. Can we come back to it this afternoon?" Then we need to come back to it. Taking a pause can help us respond thoughtfully; leaving the conversation unfinished gives the other person something else to interpret.
What happens afterward matters just as much. If we change something because of the feedback, we can acknowledge that. If we make a different decision, we can explain why. People don't need to get their way every time, but they do need to know their input received more than a polite thank-you.
And if we've handled feedback poorly before, there may be some repair to do. "I got defensive when you brought that up, and I didn't give you a fair chance to explain" is a place to start. We can't ask people to trust a new invitation while pretending the last conversation didn't happen.
The next time you're tempted to say, "My team knows they can tell me anything," think about the last time someone told you something you didn't want to hear. How did you respond? What might they have learned from that exchange, and would it make the next honest conversation easier or harder?
We can value civility and still make room for difficult truths. In fact, that's part of the work. The way we treat people when they disagree with us tells them far more than an invitation to speak freely ever will.